Politics, Technology, and Language

If thought corrupts language, language can also corrupt thought — George Orwell

The housing market – everything you know is bad

Posted by metaphorical on 28 November 2007

The most popular article here for the past week has been a March piece, “The housing market: everything you know is wrong.”

You might wonder about why, except that there’s lots of news on the housing front, all bad. For example, there’s this in today’s NY Times.

Home Prices Post Big Drop in Survey

Housing prices fell the most in almost 20 years this summer, and consumers remain deeply skeptical about the economy, according to reports released yesterday.

Prices of single-family homes in the third quarter fell 4.5 percent nationwide compared with a year ago, according to the Standard & Poor’s/Case-Shiller National Home Price Index. It was the largest drop since records for the index began in 1988.

A separate survey by S.& P./Case-Shiller of home prices in 20 major metropolitan areas showed a drop of 4.95 percent in September from a year ago, the biggest decline in more than six years. Prices declined 0.9 percent in September alone, and were down in all 20 areas, the survey found.

As well, Reuters reports that

Existing home sales fall to record low

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Sales of previously owned homes fell 8.0 percent in September to a record low 5.04 million unit pace amid troubles in the subprime mortgage and credit markets, the National Association of Realtors said on Wednesday.

It was the lowest sales pace since the realtor group began tracking both single-family and condo sales jointly in 1999.

What we’re seeing is the effects of a number of trends, which take a long time to show up in a market like housing. There’s the sub-prime mortgage fiasco, the slackness of the economy, the weakened dollar abroad, slower consumer spending, sluggish at best employmnet growth, the high price of gas and heating oil, and a vast lack of confidence in the economy.

Pricing data in particular is misleading, because we don’t know anything like a true market value until a home is actually sold. So for example, someone lists their home for $300,000. They get no bites and eventually, a year later, sell it for $200,000. What was the market value during that year? Arguably something much closer to $200,000 than $300,000. And it certainly isn’t the $330,000 that they paid for it three years earlier.

The longer people wait to sell, the more misleading pricing data is. We also don’t really know how many people want to sell their homes, so we don’t even have good supply-vs-demand data. What we do know is that the housing market is collapsing, and it was the only thing behind whatever good enconomic news we’ve had for the past few years. It’s going to be a poor Christmas season for most merchants, and that’s going to provide more bad news for the next quarter or two at least.

One Response to “The housing market – everything you know is bad”

  1. Swanny said

    Nah, it says that a lot of people who’ve been hearing for years about the “housing boom” tried to cash in (which coincides with the boomers reaching retirement age and looking to see and move south to sit on the beach condo communities) and overpriced their homes only to find that despite the fact that apartments in manhattan are increasing in value exponentially, their three bedroom in Rhode Island is not worth $1.8 million even with the pool and tennis court.

    It’s correcting, markets do that. Just like the stock market did after the dot com bubble burst. We survived that too.

    Had so many lenders not been in such a rush to loan money to people who hadn’t the slightest hope of ever managing to pay off a pair of Nikes bought on the installment plan much less a 30 year mortgage, we wouldn’t be quite so fucked.

    But that’s what you get for trying to include the poor in the ownership society.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: